Monday, March 06, 2017
Johan Galtung’s view from Europe: The “Karma Year” and Current Conflicts
The “Karma Year” and Current Conflicts
6 March 2017
Winter Conference, The Inland University, Rena, Norway, 16 Feb 2017
An Unstable World: Analysis, Forecasting, Solutions
Take current deep conflicts in our unstable world and go back in time, aided by dialogue with the parties about “when did it go wrong”. Chances are a year will emerge. There was a basic event, or process, polarizing something that used to be more cohesive. A faultline had emerged that can last for centuries, more or less polarized, up till today, and beyond, if there is no intervention.
The faultlines function like tectonic plates. Nothing may happen for long periods. Then they shock against each other, with earthquakes geo-physically; Norway-, Euro-, World-quakes socially.
The tern “karma year” is used. Not destiny-Schicksal-skjebne; too deterministic. Karma is destiny that can be changed through awareness.
The reader will find on the next page a Table with seven “current conflicts” and their Karma year(s) as hypotheses. And analysis, forecasting, solutions, here called diagnosis, prognosis, therapy. That table, or matrix, is a two-dimensional discourse for karma years. The table can be read in several ways.
Horizontally it reads like the TRANSCEND approach to conflicts: get a hold on the basic incompatibility, make a prognosis of what will happen without intervention; if unacceptable, intervene with therapy.
Vertically the first column is a study of karma years, the second of (alarming) forecasting, the third column a repertory of solutions. Our focus being on the karma years we shall read vertically.
The first impression is that the years are by and large unknown. And yet they set the tone, or throw the shadows, for centuries. How can we allow ourselves the arrogance of such ignorance?
Take Libya. How many in Italy were aware of the horrendous 1911 crime of bombing oases, the open spaces for women-young-old-infirm? Given the general rule that perpetrators forget easily, victims never?
| Diagnosis | Prognosis | Therapy | |
| 0 Libya | Bombing 1911 State terrorism | Colonizing, Liberation 1969 | Apology 2011 Silviu Berlusconi |
| 1 Afghanistan | Durand line 1893 | Pashtun split` Taliban fight | Drop Durand Central Asian Community |
| 2 Iraq-Syria | Baghdad 1258 Sykes-Picot 1916 Four colonies Osman collapse UK-French rule | Fight for independence Fight for Shia Sunni Kurdish communities | Regenerate some unity Loose federalism based on provinces Double identities |
| 3 Islamic State | Sykes-Picot 1916 NATO 1949 European Community 1958 European Union 1992 Islam as new enemy 1992 | Remove states Balance NATO Islamic State Caliphate for Mecca Retribution with moderation Western warfare | Military defense against threats, not attack-killing Negotiate Riyadh space for Israel Compensation for state terrorism |
| 4 Ukraine “at the border” | West-East 395 Schism 1054 Russian-Orthodox Crimea 1954 gift recovered | Not unitary; Not president from one nation Internal anti-Russians war; External inter- ventions. | Ukraine federation with two nations; Cabinet with 3, 5, 7 members; President rotating; Neutrality |
| 5 Israel-Palestine | Genesis 15:18 as geopolitics Chosen People, Promised Land. Divine mandate “Peace through security” | Conquest, colonialism, Terrorism, State terrorism, Expansionism US full cooperation | 1 Palestine fully recognized by all 2 states together 6 states community 20 states OSCWA “Security through peace” |
| 6 USA- all over | Divine mandate New Canaan 1620 Chosen People, promised land: Exceptionalism beyond law with promised world. Imperial global structure World currency | US empire decline and fall by 2020 (only UK-Dk-N fight US wars); USA warfare alone to keep empire; US$ declining, Currency baskets; China passing USA; Rise of East, South | Secularization, Enlightenment as normal country; MEXUSCAN N-America; Stop wars, military interventionism; Lifting the bottom 70% into the economy Working for a basket with US$ |
The key karma years are bold faced.
For the Islamic State, there are Western escalations to killing 100,000 in Afghanistan from 2001 and one million in Iraq from 2003.
For Israel, there is none as it is unclear exactly when Yahweh approached Abraham; hence a verse in the Tora’h-Old Testament-Qur’an.
Understanding karma years is not sufficient, but necessary; being the key to prognosis and therapy. Something created faultlines with much direct and structural violence. Undo them, and solutions may be possible. Ignore them, and whatever you do will be unsuccessful.
Take Libya. Berlusconi apologized, and there has been no Islamic State terrorism in Italy, or from Libya, only massive migration.
Take Afghanistan. There is no claim that all fighting is due to dividing the Pashtun nation, but it is a key factor. Undo it, open the border, and more borders, for a wealthy Central Asian Community. Or build a border wall (the USA right now) and worsen the conflict.
Take Iraq-Syria, two of the four colonies from the Sykes-Picot treason; a lesson in what a Western promise is worth. The Ottomans brutally conquered the area in 1516, but ruled peacefully for four centuries. Generate something similar, province-based federations.
Take the Islamic State and acknowledge that it was generated by escalating Western–“US-led coalition”–warfare. Kill them, and get more effect from that same cause over time. Instead, use Western military defensively to protect exposed sites, try to understand their Mecca-Medina spiritual mission against the Saudi kingdom, negotiate.
Take Ukraine with a karma year 1,600 years back. Pope Francis and Patriarch Kirill declared their Christianities one and the same, with regional conflicts to solve–like the 1812 and 1941 karma years when Russia was invaded by Napoleon and Stalin–and go for Swiss solutions.
Take Israel-Palestine, and invite Jews to live all over in that land (as they did, being people of “The Book”), but not as a big state for Jews only. Go for a modest Israeli state–like in 1-2-6-20.
Take the USA, that now may take care of themselves; soldiers and politicians denounce foreign wars and focus inward, “buying American-hiring American”. Trump is ambiguous, but may not last even 100 days.
Undo the karma years. Or ignore them, at considerable risk.
__________________________________________
Johan Galtung, a professor of peace studies, dr hc mult, is founder of the TRANSCEND Network for Peace, Development and Environment and rector of the TRANSCEND Peace University-TPU. Prof. Galtung has published 1670 articles and book chapters, over 470 Editorials for TRANSCEND Media Service, and 167 books on peace and related issues, of which 41 have been translated into 35 languages, for a total of 135 book translations, including ‘50 Years-100 Peace and Conflict Perspectives,’ published by the TRANSCEND University Press-TUP.
This work is licensed under a CC BY-NC 4.0 License.
Post a Comment
Requiring those Captcha codes at least temporarily, in the hopes that it quells the flood of comment spam I've been receiving.