Monday, August 21, 2023



From the press release:


The motion for a preliminary injunction seeks immediate relief from irreparable harm

caused by the City and County of Honolulu’s targeted enforcement actions.

HONOLULU, HI – The American Civil Liberties Union of Hawai‘i (ACLU of Hawai‘i), on

behalf of five houseless plaintiffs, filed a motion for preliminary injunction on Friday

in a lawsuit against

the City and County of Honolulu challenging enforcement actions that violate the rights

of houseless individuals under the Hawaiʻi Constitution.

The lawsuit filed last month in the First Circuit Court of Hawaii alleges that in the

absence of sufficient shelter space for Honolulu’s houseless community, the City’s

enforcement of anti-houseless laws–which include public sleeping bans, park closure

rules, displacement laws, sit/lie bans, and restrictions on keeping personal belongings

and animals–unjustly criminalizes innocent acts of survival that houseless people have

no choice but to perform in public places.

The motion filed on Friday asserts that the City’s use of sweeps constitutes cruel or

unusual punishment under the Hawaiʻi Constitution and asks the court to order the City

to immediately stop targeted enforcement actions—including sweeps, citations, and

arrests—to prevent further irreparable harm while the merits of the case are being

litigated. The motion is supported by written testimony from all five named plaintiffs

and statements from other houseless and non-houseless declarants and service providers

who expand upon the irreparable harm done to houseless residents during and in the

aftermath of the City’s sweeps and other enforcement actions.

“Our plaintiffs and the thousands of other houseless individuals living unsheltered on

Oʻahu have suffered and continue to suffer extraordinary harms,” says ACLU of Hawaiʻi

Staff Attorney Taylor Brack. “The personal stories we hear from our clients are

heartbreaking and illustrate the irreparable and systemic harm caused by the City’s

anti-houseless campaign of criminalization, harassment, and displacement.”

In her declaration, Gina Mahelona, the lead plaintiff in the lawsuit, describes the

trauma of being targeted through sweeps, citations, and arrests: “It is very stressful

to live every day bracing for something bad to happen. The City has arrested me numerous

times since I’ve been houseless. Most of the time, it was because the police had a

warrant for me based on a previous citation related to my houseless status. I can recall

many times I was arrested when I was simply going about my life: cooking, spending time

with my dogs, or even sleeping. I believe I was being targeted and profiled because of my

houseless status.”

Mahelona, a 51-year-old woman of Native Hawaiian and Puerto Rican descent who was born

and raised in Kāneʻohe, became involuntarily houseless after she lost her place in

subsidized housing when her mom, whom she cared for, passed away eight years ago. She

currently lives with her boyfriend and three dogs under a bridge in Kaimukī where they

have no access to clean running water. “This is not a good place to live: there is

nowhere to shower or use the bathroom, and we have to sleep and cook within a few feet of

a dirty waterway that sometimes floods. But [the City] basically forced us into this

location through near-constant harassment when we tried to live elsewhere”

“The City’s actions take a devastating toll on our houseless neighbors and do nothing

to solve the problem of houselessness,” says ACLU of Hawaiʻi Legal Director Wookie

Kim. “Criminalizing houselessness destabilizes and makes houseless people more

vulnerable while also undermining the mutual aid communities they depend on for


Kim says, “Despite attempts to resolve disputes with the City without litigation and

given recent reports that they have tripled their houseless enforcement


leanup-crew-efforts/>, this request for immediate injunctive relief is of great public

interest.” The motion will be heard by the court on Oct. 4.

Statements from plaintiffs and declarants are available at the ACLU of Hawaiʻi website

and arehighlighted below:

Michael David Bryan (Plaintiff) describes what it’s like to be constantly targeted by

law enforcement:

“I know that I have rights under the law, including a right to privacy, but the City

does not respect those rights. Just because I am houseless, HPD officers seem to feel

they are entitled to invade my space, interrogate me, go through my personal effects,

take away my belongings, and order me to leave an area, even when they have no legitimate

reason to believe I’ve engaged in any criminal activity. I want this harassment and

cruelty to stop. I think I should be treated the same way as people who are housed.”

Faimafili “Fili” Tupuola (Plaintiff) describes how interactions with police officers

cause her immense fear and anxiety:

“These sweeps and police encounters make me feel violated. The police have torn up my

belongings right in front of my eyes, choosing to trash what I’ve built up and saved

for. It is dehumanizing. I am already houseless, and the police sweeps add so much more

to my struggle. At night, I have such a restless sleep because I am constantly listening

and staying aware so that I do not lose my things again. The lack of sleep makes it

harder for me to take care of myself and stay vigilant to protect myself. The way the

City and HPD have treated me is traumatizing.”

Jared “Spider” Castro (Plaintiff) was one of the primary caregivers for his romantic

and life partner, Georgette Preston, who had a disability and serious medical conditions

that limited her mobility. He describes the City’s callous treatment of people with

disabilities and the particularly harmful impact houseless sweeps had on his family:

“The City confiscated a total of three wheelchairs (sized specially to fit

Georgette’s frame) and two electric scooters from Georgette. During one sweep where I

was present, we asked City staff to leave her scooter because it is her only means to

move, yet they still took it. This significantly affected how Georgette could move around

to the point where she was not able to go to [the] bathroom on her own. This was very

shocking to our family, and I know that Georgette felt shame and guilt for the impact her

dependence [had] on us.”

Georgette died in August 2022 while in custody at Oahu Community Correctional Center.

Castro’s family has never been offered an emergency shelter space ahead of an

encampment sweep. “When I was caring for Georgette, we needed ADA compliant bottom

floor shelter spaces which are extremely limited.  Georgette and I were told by shelter

workers that we were not eligible for emergency shelter space for a variety of reasons,

including because the shelters would not accommodate Georgette’s disabilities. Now, I

would be reluctant to go back to the shelters that previously turned Georgette away.”

Desmond Canite (Plaintiff) suffers from an acute case of cellulitis (a bacterial

infection) in both legs that causes severe, chronic pain and swelling when he stands for

longer than twenty minutes at a time. He describes how the City’s frequent and severe

harassment has displaced him from the community and services he needs to manage his

condition making it difficult for him to access care:

“I would rather live in town near my friends and community, and where more restaurants,

grocery stores, medical services, and other services are located, but I am forced to live

out on Sand Island just to get some peace and to be free of harassment.”

Prior to living in Sand Island, he spent a little over a year at Hale Mauliola, a shelter

consisting of converted shipping containers. “I was pleased to be living there. The

containers offered privacy and safety, and appeared to be clean, which was good for my

cellulitis. I was hopeful that the case workers would connect me to housing. I realized

over time that [it] was not sanitary.  There are lots of feral cats in the area that

urinate and defecate all over the place, which made it difficult to keep my legs clean. 

My cellulitis got worse over time because the conditions were unsanitary. Eventually, I

was kicked out of Hale Mauliola because I could not pay the required $150 per month in

rent. It is not possible for me to pay $150 per month in rent because I cannot work due

to my cellulitis.”

Miosoto Santiago-Miliatao (Declarant) recounts one traumatic experience of being arrested

while sweeping the pavilion at the Mōʻiliʻili park where she was staying:

“I was told that I was being arrested for violating park rules, but I still cannot

figure out which rules I was violating. I was arrested around lunchtime when the park was

open. I was in jail all night and then released right back onto the streets. The worst

part is that the City took all my possessions away. That included a whole bundle of

groceries I had just purchased and prenatal vitamins I had received at the PATH health

clinic. Now, I am pregnant with no food, and I won’t be able to get prenatal vitamins

again until I go back to the health clinic.”

Christopher “Paco” Fuentes Yasay (Declarant) describes how police arbitrarily and

selectively enforce anti-homeless laws:

“I do my best to follow the rules. Sometimes the enforcement of the park rules and

regulations don’t seem fair or reasonable because the HPD officers tell us that the

park rules apply only to people who look like they are houseless. For example, none of

the officers I have talked to can explain to me why I am not allowed to hang my hammock

during the daytime, but other people who look housed are allowed to hang hammocks."

ACLU of Hawaiʻi “Decriminalizing Houselessness in Hawaiʻi” Report:


Post a Comment

Requiring those Captcha codes at least temporarily, in the hopes that it quells the flood of comment spam I've been receiving.

<< Home


page is powered by Blogger. Isn't yours?

Newer›  ‹Older