Tuesday, September 20, 2011


We Need Everything

By Henry Curtis

The issue of the HCEI Energy Agreement and Big Wind popped up at DBEDT’s 3rd  Asia Pacific Clean Energy Summit & Expo (APCE) held at the Hawai`i Convention Center this month.

The mantra of the Hawai`i Clean Energy Initiative (HCEI) is that we need everything. Within the details of the HCEI proposal, some things are included, some are excluded, some are fast tracked, and some have been included but then altered or eliminated.

Raising Islands (Jan TenBruggencate's Blog, September 18, 2011) "No single energy technology will solve the world’s issues with renewable energy.  That’s a key message of the Asia Pacific Clean Energy Summit and Expo, which was held Sept. 13-15 at the Honolulu Convention Center. It’s not a new message, certainly, but it’s apparently one a lot of folks still need to learn. ...

And yet, the rifts were obvious. Wind versus geothermal. Ocean thermal versus solar.  And there were even battles within sectors.  This wind generator versus that one. Utility-scale photovoltaic versus distributed rooftop photovoltaic.

Lt. Gov. Brian Schatz said  the state’s initiative to reduce dependence on imported fossil fuels requires those divisions be set aside. 'We have the most aggressive public policy  in clean energy in the nation,' he said. And then he added: 'If we’re going to get to 70 percent clean energy, we need everything and everyone.'”

There are those who believe that Hawai`i could be 100% energy self-sufficient using only Ocean Thermal Energy Conversion (OTEC); or only relying on Ocean Wave Energy Systems (WEC); or by using a combination of wind, solar and batteries.

Some scientific types believe that the only reason for saying we need everything is to avoid taking a "hard look" at alternatives. If all technologies were laid side-by-side and analyzed in terms of reliability,  risk, cost, local production, community values, climate impacts, etc., some projects would be accepted and other projects would be rejected.

Hawai`i has had some experience where bad projects have been placed at the head of the queue, and arguments were made that since we need everything they should be automatically approved by regulators. For example, palm oil biodiesel is often made from palm oil plantations clear-cut from tropical rainforests. The plantations have devastating environmental, social, cultural and climate impacts.

Oahu Solar Potential

Obviously the amount of solar energy falling on O`ahu can power the entire state and perhaps most if not all of California.  But questions remain regarding how much solar energy can actually be captured on Oahu.

Last year CleanTechnica stated the obvious: “Catch an aerial view of Pearl Harbor and it’s easy to see the potential for rooftop solar energy.   Parts of the U.S. Navy base in Hawaii are open space but much of it is a dense conglomeration of buildings and facilities, and every roof could be a potential sustainable energy generator.”

The Naval Facilities Engineering Command (NAVFAC) Pacific published a  Request For Proposals (RFP) for private industry to build, own and operate solar facilities on Hawai`i military bases.

NAVFAC Pacific furnished, as part of the solicitation package, the square footage of roof tops, carports, and ground-mount sites located on military installations in Hawaii.”

A Navy Press Release stated: “NAVFAC awarded three companies -- Island Pacific Energy LLC, Pacific Energy Solutions LLC, and Photon Finance LLC -- a contract worth up to $500 million to install solar panels at the Joint Base Pearl Harbor-Hickam, Marine Corps Base Hawaii, Schofield Barracks, Wheeler Army Airfield, Tripler Army Medical Center, Fort DeRussy, Asia Pacific Center for Strategic Studies, Naval Computer and Telecommunications Area Master Station, Naval Magazine West Loch, the Pacific Missile Range Facility on Kauai and the Army Reserve Center on Maui.”

In Hawai`i, new 5 MW solar farms on non-military land are in the regulatory stage for Kalaeloa facilities and in the planning stage for central O`ahu facilities.  Research teams led by University of Hawai`i’s Steven Meder have studied in detailed the roof characteristics of the Iwilei industrial area; the University of Hawai`i, Manoa Campus; and Coconut Island.


Sempra is building the 8 turbine Auwahi Wind Farm with a 10 MWh battery storage system at Ulupalakua Ranch on Maui.

Sempra has built the largest solar farm in the U.S. The 48 MW Copper Mountain Solar facility is located in Boulder City, Nevada about 40 miles southeast of Las Vegas.

Sempra is in the process of building the world’s  largest solar farm. The 150 MW, 4000 acres (6 square mile) Mesquite Solar Complex in located in Arlington, Arizona about 40 miles west of Phoenix.

Sempra proposed to the Navy that Sempra invest $1 billion to build a 300 MW photovoltaic solar facility on unused land at Pearl Harbor to be located on unused military land that the military may wish to land bank for future military expansion. Sempra is also proposing to build a 50 MW solar farm facility at Lualualei.  

For the 300 MW solar farms at Pearl Harbor, Sempra is proposing to give the military 25 MW of the electricity at no cost in exchange for the use of the Navy property and charging HECO 17 cents per kilowatt-hour for the other 275 MW. HECO estimates the wholesale cost of Big Wind to be 21 cents per kilowatt-hour.

The facility would be “developed, owned and operated by Sempra, 100%. It's about a billion dollar project and Sempra would paying  all of the cost of that under a Enhanced Use Lease (EUL) process. ...we could get it up and running by 2014.”

Although the Sempra proposal in not in accordance with the Navy RFP because the proposal involves only ground-mounted systems, the Sempra proposal expands the envelope of what can be done on O`ahu.

The HCEI Road Map

There was also an unusual leaflet found at the conference called the “HCEI Road Map: Introduction & Overview, 2011 Edition” published by DBEDT.  The document stated in a few places: “see Road Map” for more details without any address or website to get such a Road Map. Going to the DBEDT web site produced no meaningful results. I finally located the August 2011 Road Map on a federal website. 

The HCEI Road Map states: “At its core, HCEI has been designed to be a collaborative effort between all of the citizens of the State of Hawaii to leverage their respective strengths in achieving a clean energy future that will benefit not just its constituents but the future citizens of the State as well.”

Odd, since HCEI meetings were frequently held behind closed doors without public notice and I had to petition DBEDT last year to find out who the members of the committees were.

Big Wind

The panel on “Foundation for Clean Energy Future - Policies, Strategies, and Frameworks That Transform the Energy Market “ provided an opportunity for Senator Mike Gabbard, PUC Chair Hermina Morita and HECO VP Robbie Alm to discuss their ideas. After they spoke, the audience asked questions.

“My name is Walter Ritte, and I'm from Moloka`i, which is the first wave of, this energy stuff coming that need to feed Oahu. So I was really agreeing with a lot of things.  I like all of your analogies of being addicts.

The question I have is for the policy makers. I wanted to know if there was a political will, on the part of the State, to sort of level the playing field about, who's going to sacrifice what, in order for us to get, these things that we want to get. Right now their asking us on the island if Moloka`i and the island of Lana`i, to sacrifice, our social and cultural values in order to get to where we want to go.

I wanted to know if there's a political will on the part of the Legislature, to have the people of Oahu, sacrifice some of their social ways of living, because the talk we have on the Outside Islands is why should we, keep feeding the beast, it's going to be endless. It's not a matter of being addicts to black oil or green oil. It's a matter of being addicts to power and being wasteful.

So, that's how we talk on the Outside Islands. We would share, but, it has to be a two-way street.

If were going to sacrifice what their asking us to sacrifice,  people need to sacrifice on this end. So I wanted to know if there is actually a political will to do that with this community, on this site that meets all of this. They want to connect all of the islands, we want to be independent on all of them.  We want to be independent but if they want us to connect all of us. Then is there going to be political will to change the lifestyles, not, by words but by actual laws.”

Senator Gabbard stated that “as far as the political will, it remains to be seen.”

Chair Morita stated: “You know I think it is all how you frame the issue. It's not us against them. Neighbor Islands against Oahu. What is the reality if we stay on this course for all of us throughout the State? And I think those are the kinds of issues that we have to really look at. You know one of the things that is rarely discussed is what are the benefits that can be brought to the Neighbor Islands. The issue of community benefits agreement, in helping to mitigate some of these issues before us. But definitely we can not stay  no matter where you are in Hawai`i. We can not stay on this course. So how do we design the system, that will benefit all of us and leave nobody or no island behind.”

Ocean Thermal Energy Conversion (OTEC)

Lockheed Martin had been planning on deploying an OTEC facility in the waters off Hawai`i next year. Instead they have sought to lock in 5 years of taxpayer funded Stimulus funds to conduct more research and to patent the results.

OTECorporation is moving aggressively into building OTEC in the Caribbean.

There is concern by OTEC proponents regarding a new rule being proposed by the U.S. EPA. The rule is focused on manufacturing facilities and power plants located along ocean, river and lake shorelines but may adversely impact an ocean-based OTEC facility.

Since 2001 the U.S. EPA has been adopting rules to regulate cooling water intake structures (CWISs) under the Section 316(b) of the Clean Water Act re the National Pollutant Discharge Elimination System (NPDES) permit system.

The EPA is working on a new proposedfinal rule that would cover roughly 1,260 existing facilities -- 590 manufacturing facilities, 670 power plants -- that each withdraw at least 2 million gallons/day of cooling water. Under the terms of a lawsuit settlement agreement the final rule must be signed by July 27, 2012.

The withdrawal of cooling water from streams, rivers, estuaries and coastal marine waters by CWISs causes Adverse Environmental Impacts (AEI) to aquatic biota and communities in these water bodies. These impacts are caused through several means, including impingement mortality (where fish and other aquatic life are trapped on equipment at the entrance to the CWIS) and entrainment mortality (where aquatic organisms, including eggs, and larvae are taken into the cooling system, passed through the heat exchanger, then discharged back into the source body). Additional adverse effects are often associated with CWIS operation, including nonlethal effects of impingement, thermal discharges, chemical effluents, flow modifications caused by these plants, and other impacts of variable and unknown magnitudes.”

# # #


Post a Comment

Requiring those Captcha codes at least temporarily, in the hopes that it quells the flood of comment spam I've been receiving.

Links to this post:

Create a Link

<< Home


page is powered by Blogger. Isn't yours?

Newer›  ‹Older